The constitution Safeguards Us: Separation of Powers and Inhibiting the Consolidation of governmental Authority v Checks and also Balances
The Founders very closely laid the structure of America’s superstructure the liberty by developing within the U.S. Constitution’s architectural framework an enlightened system that distributes the strength allotted to government amongst its ingredient parts. They go this due to the fact that they taken that centralized state power, even within a republic, normally leads come the abuse the power and loss that freedom. As James Madison explained, “
This ingenious political construct of America’s federal government that safeguards liberty by preventing the consolidation that state government is the 3rd foundational rule of the Constitution: Separation the Powers and also its coordinate device of check and also balances.2
In every federal government there space three species of power: legislative, executive, and judicial. The U.S. Constitution divides this powers right into separate, coordinate, and also equal branches the government. The Framers intentionally prevented any single branch of government from ending up being too an effective by specifically limiting the strength of each and also creating an inner system that checks and balances amongst the different branches. The result is a device of self-government the assiduously diffuses central power. No branch of government can arrogate to itself what strength it pleases. America’s structure grants sufficient power come govern if constraining the capacity to abridge the for free of the administer by separating the mighty powers to legislate, execute, and adjudicate, and also by offering each branch the means to stand up to the blandishments and also incursions that the others.
You are watching: How the constitution safeguards and limits individual rights
The Framers did this due to the fact that they understood, favor Montesquieu prior to them, the difference between liberty and also democracy.3 The two are by no method synonymous; indeed, history teaches that tyranny have the right to be that worst when exercised in the name of the sovereignty of the people.4 liberty exists only as soon as there is no abuse that power, regardless of the form of government. We have actually learned by sad endure that every human being invested through power is apt to abuse it and carry the authority as far as it will certainly go.5 Often, liberty is put into existence within a particular type of government, such as a democracy, and the power of the human being is perplexed with the liberty that the people. Liberty, however, is not just doing what one pleases. True liberty in its finish sense has actually two parts: an individual or separation, personal, instance liberty, consisting of the cost-free exercise that one’s own will and conscience; and also political or social liberty, consists of one’s security and also safety if living among peers in an ordered and civil society.6 Both aspects must be present for liberty come exist. Therefore, establishing a government that both promises the natural right to practice conscience easily in search of one’s happiness, and also to carry out so in ~ a society that hold this best inviolable and also secure native unjust interference through others, is the very essence of forming a an ext perfect union. This is the majestic work the Framers sought when creating the Constitution. That is what man Adams referred to as the “divine science” of the perfect federal government for liberty—enabling liberty to show up in its highest possible perfection.7
With this clean understanding, john Adams, perhaps over all his peers, captured the political vision that Montesquieu. Adams understood that one indispensable safeguard against tyranny and the insurance of true liberty lies in the separation of the executive, legislative, and judicial strength of government. Favor Montesquieu, Adams comprehended the subtle but significant difference between independence and liberty. A country may victory its independence, yet a human being will accomplish liberty only when federal government protects their natural rights and refrains native abusing their delegated authority. Accordingly, in 1780, Adams contained the concept of separation of strength in the commonwealth of Massachusetts Constitution, which to be the first time in the history of the human being that the concept had been embraced as a form of government. A couple of years later he ensured it was in the U.S. Constitution, hoping to see arise in America an “empire of liberty” of free people, without one noble or one king among them.8
The U.S. Constitution developments the principle of separation of strength in remarkable and profound means that builds on the brilliance that Montesquieu and early initiatives of Adams in pursuing the perfect government for liberty. Both guys discerned the each of the departments of federal government must be different in its attributes but additionally subject come the checks of the others two, lest one department become abusive in performing its attributes to the risk of the people’s individual and collective liberty. Strength must inspect power by the arrangement of things, and bulwarks past mere parchment are essential to safeguard the people versus the encroaching spirit of power. James Madison, together a main architect that liberty, joined in this noble pursuit of perfect government and, in enhancement to creating the an initial drafts of the U.S. Constitution v its progressive system of checks and also balances, dedicated five Federalist papers (Nos. 47-51) to explain the wisdom of the principle. Madison’s masterful hand elevated the political ethics of his predecessors right into an elegant constitutional device that both diffuses strength to protect liberty and also integrates these spread powers into a workable government: as Justice Jackson has actually written, “It enjoins upon its branches separateness yet interdependence, autonomy but reciprocity.”9
Our nation’s other greatest Founders mutual the politics intelligence and constitutional acumen the Adams and also Madison. Among them, thomas Jefferson, Alexander Hamilton, and also George Washington particularly understood the vital constitutional rule of separation that powers, including the U.S. Constitution’s device of checks and balances. “The top principle that our structure is the independence of the Legislature, Executive and also Judiciary of every other,” Jefferson explained.10 come James Madison, Jefferson wrote, “The principle of the constitution is the of a separation of Legislative, Executive and Judiciary functions, except in cases specified. If this principle be no expressed in direct terms, it is clearly the heart of the Constitution, and it must be therefore commented and also acted on by every girlfriend of cost-free government.”11
Alexander Hamilton concurred: “The same rule which teaches the propriety of a partition between the assorted branches of power, teaches us an in similar way that this partition ought to be for this reason contrived regarding render the one independent of the other.”12 “For i agree, ‘that over there is no liberty if the power of evaluate be not separated native the legislative and executive powers.’” 13
Finally, consider the way admonition of George Washington in his Farewell resolve concerning the meaning of the an essential constitutional rule of separation that powers, which contained a strict admonition to every those that would fulfill the to trust afforded by the American people when offer in your government:
It is important, likewise, the the actions of thinking in a complimentary country should inspire fist in those entrusted with its management to confine themselves within their respective constitutional spheres, preventing in the practice of the powers of one department to encroach top top another. The spirit of encroachment has tendency to consolidate the strength of every the departments in one, and also thus to create, every little thing the kind of government, a actual despotism. The requirement of reciprocal checks in the practice of political power, by dividing and also distributing that into different depositaries, and constituting each the guardian of the public weal against invasions through the others, has actually been evinced by experiments ancient and modern; some of them in ours country and under our own eyes. To keep them must be as necessary as to institute them.14
Washington more warned in clearly terms against those who could be tempted come unwisely academy arbitrary transforms to a coordinate branch of government for political acquire by recall them that the just legal and also proper way to readjust the delicate balance amongst the people’s disseminated powers amongst their three branches of federal government is by constitution amendment, together expressly collection forth in the Constitution. That was many resolute on this point: “But let there be no change by usurpation; for through this, in one instance, might be the instrument of good, the is the customary weapon by which complimentary governments space destroyed.”
And finally, we have actually Washington’s conditional promise worrying the fundamental constitutional principle of separation the powers. It was given directly to every future generation that will inherit and also carry top top America’s standard of self-government to the world: If us honor the precepts set forth in the Constitution and “resist with care the heart of development upon that is principles” … climate “Liberty itself will discover in together a government, through powers effectively distributed and adjusted, that is surest guardian.”15
The U.S. Structure safeguards the American people listed that us stand fast in the liberty and also constitutional principles wherewith that is authors have actually made united state free. Unfortunately, too couple of today understand the definition of the constitutional principle of separation that powers and also its coordinate mechanism of checks and also balances. Too few serving in federal government refrain native the seductive propensity to undertaking into the field of a coordinate branch come which they to be neither chosen nor appointed. We as lawyers and judges, as guardians of the Constitution, have a obligation to education them and to adhere to this constitutional principles ourselves, when applicable. As Montesquieu taught once writing the essays that guided our founders on the truest ethics of liberty and also government: Our organization here is “not around making world read, but about making human being think.”16 might it be claimed of us as we attend to the standard raised up by our Founders, that us fulfilled our duty and also preserved true liberty. The tribute paid by Voltaire come Montesquieu expresses the gratitude that we owe to our American Founders and also all those engaged in the cause of freedom: “The human household had lost its title deeds—Montesquieu discovered them and restored them to your owner.”
Download PDF Here
About the Author
W. West Allen is the present President of the FBA and also an intellectual property litigator and also counselor in las Vegas who represents a wide range of global clients in commonwealth courts. He served as chair that the FBA’s federal government Relations Committee for seven years and also has offered as a member that the FBA’s board of directors for much of the past decade. In 2016, Allen got the FBA’s President’s Award for longstanding business to the FBA and as chair the its government Relations Committee.
See more: How Much Does The Average Ant Weigh ?: Rickandmorty How Much Do Ants Weigh
About the FBA
Founded in 1920, the federal Bar association is devoted to the development of the scientific research of jurisprudence and to fostering the welfare, interests, education, and also professional advancement of all attorneys involved in federal law. Our more than 16,000 members run the gamut of federal practice: attorneys practicing in small to huge legal firms, attorneys in corporations and federal agencies, and also members of the judiciary. The FBA is the catalyst for communication in between the bar and also the bench, and also the private and public sectors. Visit united state at altoalsimce.org to find out more.