Whosever room this is need to be ashamed! His underwear is hanging on the lamp. His raincoat is over there in the overstuffed chair, and the chair is becoming quite mucky and also damp. His workbook is wedged in the window, His sweater’s been thrown top top the floor. His scarf and one ski are beneath the TV, and his pants have actually been carelessly hung on the door. His books are every jammed in the closet, His vest has actually been left in the hall. A lizard called Ed is sleep in his bed, and also his smelly old sock has actually been stuck to the wall. Whosever room this is should be ashamed! Donald or Robert or Willie or– Huh? You speak it’s mine? Oh, dear, i knew the looked familiar!

With Shel Silverstein, that is quite simple to imagine how a room, even hardly resembling a place for a living, deserve to look like. “Messy Room” is the significance of everything that can be linked into words “untidiness” or “indifference” come yourself and also your things. Emphasizing this untidiness and also indifference, the writer even refuses to usage a rhyme which you normally expect to check out in the poem.

You are watching: Messy room by shel silverstein analysis

A Teenager’s Room?

The composition of the poem could resemble a burger. The inner “filling” is a descriptive part, if the beginning and also the end of the poem are comments. The very first words currently create a details mood: “Whosever room this is have to be ashamed!“. But what sort of the atmosphere is this? What emotion is embedded in these words? Technically, the looks like a preaching, but in truth these are formal indigenous which bring no true feeling. And also it is specifically the third part of the poem, start with the literal repetition of the an initial line (“Whosever room this is should be ashamed!“), i beg your pardon depreciates them.


The writer seems to be saying “yes, it’s terribly sloppy,” and is ready to paint this “horribly” v the brightest colors, but in fact he considers the room just as a enjoy of his own inner conflict, self-neglect and the absence of self-care. The indigenous commenting on the room (1 and also 3 parts) space most likely cited, and these space the indigenous of part adult. No wonder the most often “Messy Room” is regarded as a poem dubbed “A Teenager’s Room”. 

Pictures and smells

Such detailed summary of pictures and also local pictures in the room, favor the persons the writer suggests, creates fairly bright impression to make the reader’s brain automatically to fill this imaginary room with miscellaneous smells. This is a particular smell the raw, undried things, and also the sour smell of worn laundry and socks. And also not just socks, since “And his smelly old sock has actually been stuck to the wall“.

The images in the poem make it possible to see not simply the general photo of the outrageous disorder, but many little pictures defined in all tiny details. “His sweater was on the floor” or “His raincoat is over there in the overstuffed chair.” yet is the person walking in the room really suffering stress? Or is that looking roughly with interest, drastically shaking his head trying come condemn the disorder? most likely, this is just histrionics, deliberateness, unnaturalness.


The writer does no really condemn the disorder, he just states it. And also it is quite feasible that this declare acts together a kind of “appeal” warning against any future claims towards him.

Censure or support

At first glance, the only feasible reaction to the room could be censure, which is what the author demonstrates. However, if you take a closer look the situation changes. The writer – if we comment on his room – prevents censure, mirroring “necessary” negative reaction.

Does he ask because that help? No. Like many teens or people experiencing an inner crisis, that does not recognize that he deserve to ask for aid or he is not sure that that can obtain this help. However what can the hero of this poem need if no help, then? many likely, the acceptance. The willingness to expropriate the fact that a person can experience together harsh things inside him the external problems simply execute not matter. Exterior “horrible” pictures are simply a reflection of the inside struggle and also self-misunderstanding.

Hypocrisy

However, there is another interpretation that this poem. And the significance of that translate is hypocrisy. It is as if the dad condemns his teenage son, but at the exact same time he has the exact same disorder in his very own room. And the teenager’s protest versus the hypocrisy of adults is a herbal reaction at this age. The poem have the right to be taken into consideration as a protest that this kind.


This translate is storage of the Bible’s moral code which asks united state to get rid of the log in in our very own eye before instructing who who has actually a flush-sized flaw.

See more: What Is A Flock Of Chickens Called ? Is It A Flock Or A Brood

A teenage situation or any kind of other an overwhelming life instance is no a factor to blame to a person. ~ all, the is quite feasible that this is our own crisis, our own “room”. And it is not always perfectly clean.

*


Reviewed through Katerina Sidoruk


Related Posts


poetry analysis
previous PostThe enthusiasm of Arthur Rimbaud and also Paul VerlaineNext Post“Stopping by Woods top top a Snowy Evening” by Robert Frost