When Albus Dumbledore lastly reaches the island with Harry Potter and finds out that you can"t gain near the potion, that made a cup and drank it. Why couldn"t he just have actually poured the medicine on the "floor"? Why couldn"t he have actually made a big cup to hold practically everything inside the basin?


*

*

It was difficult to pour it on the floor. It to be majicked to just decrease from drinking. Quoting from HP6 (Chapter 26: The Cave)

... "But just how to reach it? This potion cannot be penetrated by hand, Vanished, parted, scooped up, or siphoned away, nor deserve to it be Transfigured, Charmed, or otherwise made to adjust its nature.

You are watching: What did the potion do to dumbledore

"

Almost absent-mindedly, Dumbledore raised his wand again, twirled it when in midair, and also then caught the crystal goblet that he had conjured out of nowhere.

"I have the right to only conclude that this potion is an alleged to be drunk."

"What?" said Harry. "No!"

"Yes, i think so: only by drinking it have the right to I empty the basin and also see what lies in its depths."

The reason for having it collection this way was for Voldemort come incapacitate the would-be thief so he could be interrogated further:

"... He would not desire to automatically kill the human who got to this island," Dumbledore corrected himself. "He would want to save them lively long enough to uncover out just how they regulated to penetrate so far through his defenses and, many importantly the all, why they to be so will upon emptying the basin. Carry out not forget that Lord Voldemort believes the he alone knows about his Horcruxes."

"Undoubtedly," he said, finally, "this potion have to act in a means that will stop me acquisition the Horcrux. It could paralyze me, cause me come forget what i am right here for, develop so much pain ns am distracted, or render me i can not qualify in some other way..."

Of course, for such incapacitation to occur, it is imperative the the toxicity be actually drunk, as opposed to safely disposed of.

See more: Solution: In An Ordinary Deck Of 52 Cards, How Many Cards Are Red In A Deck ?

As much as make a larger goblet - the is fairly obvious the the drink must have been done utilizing this specific goblet:

Water might not be touch in a regular method (He met an invisible barrier that prevented that coming within an customs of it)

Later, Harry do the efforts to fill the goblet v water with regular spells and also that didn"t work-related - i beg your pardon likely way it was a details goblet magicked to not contain any kind of water other than indigenous an Inferi-infested lake. This is a wee bit speculative due to the fact that that might have instead been a home of the entire cavern instead of the goblet.